Keith Burgun

GTA 6

I've never been a huge fan of the GTA games and I think a big reason for that is my background of playing CRPGs - games like the old Ultimas, or even newer games like Pillars of Eternity or Divinity Original Sin. In games like these, the player is not presumed (at all) to be a criminal; you have some general quest and you're placed into a world full of NPCs who all want something and are involved in various factions, etc etc etc. You can engage with them in a variety of ways. Some of those ways are, to varying degrees, criminal - you can steal items from them, you can steal objects in their house, you can attack people, you can go into areas you don't have permission to go into, and so on.

When a game like this calls you "criminal!", it is doing so because of choices that you made about how you're going to play. It actually feels transgressive, which I think is a very important part of doing crime in a video game. Of course they put in all the rules that allow you to steal, rules that cause NPCs and guards to react in certain ways; none of it is actually transgressive. But it is stagecrafted enough to feel transgressive, and a lot of times, the cost of criminality in these games is quite huge. It is often a big enough penalty that your guy dies or that you want to reload to a save point from before you did the crime - but not always! And that's what makes it exciting.

If I wanted to make a game where part of the thrill of the game was in doing crime, the last thing I would do is name the game "Grand Theft Auto" or something like that. Once you build your game to be clearly all about doing crime, you turned crime into the normal way of playing, and you've sucked all the transgressiveness out of it. When I play Grand Theft Auto, I basically try to avoid doing crime. If you're playing the "Do Crime Game", obeying traffic laws now becomes the way to be transgressive.

This has also affected my ability to enjoy so-called "Stealth" games. Sneaking around is fun as hell when you're not supposed to be sneaking around. If I'm supposed to be sneaking around, then sneaking around just feels like a chore.

Anyway, everyone's talking about GTA 6 so I thought I'd write something about it. I haven't played a GTA game since San Andreas and probably won't ever play this one.